Something NGJ Says That I Can Agree With

I wholeheartedly agree with this commenter, and the actual article, if you can believe it!

Source Article

I will reread the article, but I honestly can’t really find anything here that I detect as something harmful for a child.

I don’t really like how Mr. Pearl states that a child isn’t fit to go somewhere with such a “nice looking family”, because I think that is inconsiderate and disrespectfully stated, but otherwise, I can’t find fault.  Personally, I would simply state to the child that wherever the family is headed requires a certain type of clothing, and since the child did not have the proper type of clothing because he/she had not completed his/her task of whatever laundry they were responsible for, then accompanying the family would have to wait until the next opportunity.

, 20-01-10 15:41:

This is how I was raised: with real consequences (not irrelevant spankings.) I have a better relationship that any spanked child I know, and I believe that is in part because it was obvious the my problems were the direct result of my own misbehaviour, not my parents being mean. It never occured to me that as an adult I would have to *make* myself behave without my parents, because I knew screwing up was it’s own punishment. The lack of real consequences (or the assumption that these can wait until adulthood, which is in sharp conflict with the idea of training up a child) has always bothered me about your magazines. It’s nice to see them once in a while.

2 thoughts on “Something NGJ Says That I Can Agree With

  1. Mr Pearl has said a number of things that I agree with. But the parts I disagree with are so egregious, that I am forced to disavow their teachings as a whole. A broken clock is right twice a day, but I wouldn’t consult it for the time.

    • I love how you’ve said that… the clock will be correct twice a day even if broken.

      And the clock will go on thinking it is functioning perfectly, because it is still a clock. It does not know it is not functioning.

Leave a Reply to Muse Mama Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *